The New York Times
September 15, 1985, Sunday, Late City Final Edition
ABOUT MEN;
A FATHER'S ANGER
By FREDERICK KAUFMAN
IN
''BAD DAY AT BLACK ROCK,'' a film my father wrote, Robert Ryan tells
Spencer Tracy: ''Nobody around here has been big enough to make you
mad. I believe a man is as big as the things that make him mad.'' I've
never forgotten those lines. They are linked to one of my earliest
memories of my father: Dad is pacing the living room, holding the phone
under an arm like a football and screaming into the receiver, ''Don't
tell me how to write the goddamn thing!''I can't
remember exactly what was going on, but I do know that he was yelling
at an agent, a director, a producer - one of the multitude in Hollywood
who can torment a writer. I also know that I hated his rage, that I
wished for a less angry father. ''Writing,'' my father often told me,
''rhymes with fighting.''
One
afternoon, I could have been no more than 9 years old, my father and I
were in the pantry. He was up on a ladder, trying to get his pliers
into an obscure corner. It was my job to hand him the tools he needed.
My attention wandered, and soon he was yelling at me. About an hour
after his screaming subsided, Dad came to my room and apologized. ''You
are not the target,'' he told me. But I remember thinking that if I
wasn't the target, who was?Years later, my college
writing instructor asked me to her office to discuss one of my short
stories. As she critiqued my writing, I became full of rage. To calm
myself, I repeated under my breath, ''A man is as big as the things
that make him mad. . . .'' Finally I shouted, ''Don't tell me how to
write the goddamn thing!''
I was kicked out of my
first writing course, and six years elapsed before it occurred to me
that what had happened had something to do with my father.
By
then, I was living in New York in a windowless garret, working at a
small publishing house by day. At night, I typed on my Smith-Corona
portable.
It was a year of pounding out furiously whatever came to mind -damn the editors, damn the publishing industry.
I had inherited my father's stubborn rage.
When
the year was over, I needed a new typewriter. When I looked at my vast,
useless pile of paper, I had the feeling something was not right.
On
my next visit to Los Angeles, I made a point of joining my father for a
lunch of chicken hot dogs. He overcooks them in the broiler every day,
and they emerge black and swollen with raised bubbles - the way he
loves them. He covers them with mustard or ketchup or Tabasco sauce and
eats them between slices of not-quite-yet-stale French bread. No matter
who joins him -a producer, the gardener - the grub is always the same.
''Want some?'' he asks. ''No, thanks.''
But when
they're on his plate, I ask for a bite. He gives me an annoyed smile,
forks over half his meal and tosses a few more dogs on the broiler.
''Dad,'' I ask, ''why did you decide to become a writer?''
He
told me that after he had returned from the Marine Corps in World War
II, he had thought that the most sensible way to make a living, with
the least expenditure of effort, would be to write theatrical motion
pictures, about which he knew absolutely nothing. His first job was
with United Productions of America, where he had been teamed with the
director John Hubley and asked to create an original cartoon.
My
father came up with a character based on his Uncle Leonard, who was
also known as Bub. I had met Uncle Bub when he was an old man, deaf and
barrel-chested. The cartoon character needed a name; my father turned
to California geography, which, he said, is full of inherently funny
names. He loved the pretentiousness of Azusa (''Everything from A to Z
in the U.S.A.''), and Point Mugu, up the coast from Malibu. He decided
to change the spelling and call Uncle Bub Mr. Magoo.
The
cartoon was an immediate hit. But after my father had written the first
half-dozen Magoos, he left United Productions. In Dad's opinion,
writing cartoons was no job for a mature man, so even though he had hit
the jackpot early, he told his agent to get him different work. The
agent discovered that M-G-M was planning a picture about boot camp. At
that time, there were surprisingly few writers in Hollywood who, like
my father, had been in combat. The agent went to Dore Schary, vice
president in charge of production. ''I don't know whether this kid can
write,'' he told Schary, ''but if he gives you nothing more than a few
little things that are for real, at the end of the month you can him
and you get a professional writer.'' Dad got the job.
A
few weeks later, as Dad was leaving the studio, a voice hollered
''Millard!'' It was Schary. The head of the studio was charming, and
apologized for not having seen Dad earlier; he was terribly busy.
''I
tell you what let's do,'' he said. ''It's so difficult talking around
the office, there are always phones and one thing or another. Why don't
you come over to the house tomorrow morning, and we'll talk while I'm
taking a shower?''
''All the vicious and demeaning
things I had heard about the treatment of writers in Hollywood kind of
ganged up on me,'' my father told me. In a rage, he screamed at Schary,
''And what the hell shall we do then? Play unnatural games?'' My father
walked away. I pictured Mom and Dad in the living room later that
evening. Of course, Dad would have to find another job. He had had the
chance to do what he had dreamed of and rage had spoiled it. But Mom
said to hell with Schary, you're right.
So in the
kitchen, over the remains of chicken hot dogs, I realized that no
matter what the reward, my father wouldn't lick another man's boots.
His rage had a lot of good in it: I, too, will never have to read my
work to the vice presidents of this world while they soap their armpits.
And
years ago, as my parents sat brooding, the phone rang. It was Mrs.
Schary's social secretary, inviting them to dinner. My father stayed at
M-G-M for 11 years, during which time he earned two Academy Award
nominations, one for the second film of his career, that western
starring Spencer Tracy and Robert Ryan with the lines I won't forget.